Our Menu

PIZZA SIZES 10″ 14″ 16″

Sausage, Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions, Black Olives, Jalepenos, Banana Peppers, Pineapple

Supreme, All Meat, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Veggie, Bar-B-Q Chicken, Cheese

Coca Cola products along with Big Red, Mt. Dew, Diet Dr. Pepper. Refillable for dine-in or 2-liters also available


Giant Salted Pretzel Giant ballpark-style pretzel served with our nacho cheese

Breadsticks Single serving and family size. Delicious Breadsticks served with our nacho cheese sauce or marinara sauce

Cheese Bread Four slices of cheese bread

Chocolate Chip Cookie


Wings Your choice of (10) delicious Hot, BBQ, or Sherrilli’s Gold wings served with Ranch dressing.

Pickles & Chips 3 pickle spears and a bag of Ruffles

Nachos and Cheese Heaping tray of tortilla chips smothered in nacho cheese. With or without jalapenos
Large Serving of Spaghetti topped w/Mozzarella Cheese baked to perfection, served with two breadsticks

SANDWICHES     half & whole

Sausage, Cheese & Onions with Pizza Sauce served on a 12″ Hoagie Bun

Veggie Stromboli
Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions & Black Olives with Pizza Sauce served on a 12″ Hoagie Bun

Texas BBQ
Sausage, Cheese & Onions with Barbeque Sauce served on a 12″ Hoagie Bun

Hot Ham & Cheese
(The Classic) Thick Slices of Ham Topped with Mozzarella Cheese served on a 12″ Hoagie Bun

Steak Hoagie
Steak Patty with Mozzarella Cheese, Onions & Pizza Sauce served on a 12″ Hoagie Bun. Additional toppings available

SALADS (Dressings: Thousand Island, French, Ranch & Italian)

Chef Salad
A mix of Iceburg & Romaine Lettuce covered with sliced ham, bacon & mozzarella cheese. Served with two slices of toasted garlic bread. Choice of dressing

Tossed Salad
Iceburg & Romaine lettuce topped with cheese with one dressing

© 2024 Sherrilli’s Pizzeria

496 N. Indiana Ave.   Sellersburg, IN 47172